Comparison
7 Deadly Sins Test vs Enneagram, Big Five and HEXACO
The seven sins are a moral list, not a personality model. Enneagram, Big Five and HEXACO are personality models, and they do not measure the same thing. Here is the honest comparison, including where our own test sits.
The short version
Four tools get compared to each other constantly, and they are not in the same business.
| Tool | What it actually measures | Where it came from | How results are scored |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 deadly sins test (this one) | How much seven named temptations sound like you | Fourth-century monastic teaching, later folded into seven by Gregory the Great | Percentages for each vice, relative to the questions asked |
| Enneagram | One of nine types, plus a wing, plus core fear and desire | A twentieth-century teaching system with older roots | Type assignment, usually with a wing |
| Big Five (OCEAN) | Five continuous traits: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, neuroticism | Factor analysis of trait language in academic psychology | Scores on five dimensions, often with facets |
| HEXACO | Six continuous dimensions: the Big Five plus Honesty-Humility | Academic personality research, a lexical study tradition | Scores on six dimensions |
If the question is "which one is scientifically validated", the answer is Big Five or HEXACO, not the sins and not the Enneagram. If the question is "which one will make me recognise myself in a sentence", the sins and the Enneagram usually win, for the reason that named vices and named types are more memorable than a percentile on a trait.
What the 7 deadly sins test measures
Seven vices, scored separately: pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath and sloth. Five questions each, thirty-five in total, four responses per question. The output is a percentage for every vice, and the highest one is called the ruling vice.
Two things are worth being clear about. First, the percentages are relative to the questions we ask, not to a population — a 70% Wrath means you endorsed most of the wrath situations we described, not that you are angrier than 70% of people. Second, the list itself is a moral and theological scheme, not a psychometric one; it was designed for self-examination, and that is the job we are using it for.
The virtue paired with each vice is not decoration. It comes from the same tradition and gives the result somewhere to go: wrath against patience, greed against charity, pride against humility, envy against kindness, gluttony against temperance, lust against chastity, sloth against diligence. "The 7 deadly sins list" on this site has each pairing and what each vice actually names.
What the Enneagram measures
The Enneagram sorts people into nine types and hangs motivation on the number: what the type wants, what it fears, how it behaves under stress and in growth, and usually a wing that shades it toward a neighbouring type. Its appeal is narrative — a well-written Enneagram description sounds like a person, which is exactly what a five-number profile does not do.
The honest caveat is measurement. The Enneagram did not come out of academic personality research; it was developed and taught, and psychologists have argued about its reliability and validity for decades. That is a different claim from "it is wrong". It is a claim about what kind of evidence exists.
What Big Five measures
Five continuous traits — openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism — usually reported as percentiles, with longer versions measuring facets within each trait. The IPIP-NEO instruments are the common free route, at 120 or 300 items.
The strength is that it is the most heavily researched trait model in psychology, and its dimensions show up across languages and cultures. The weakness, for a casual visitor, is that a percentile on agreeableness is not a sentence you remember. It describes; it does not narrate.
What HEXACO measures
HEXACO takes the Big Five and adds Honesty-Humility: sincerity, fairness, greed avoidance and modesty, with the last two doing obvious work next to pride and greed. Standard versions run 60 or 100 items.
For anyone drawn to the sins test, Honesty-Humility is the most interesting dimension in academic psychology, because it is the closest thing in a validated instrument to the old idea of pride as the root vice. The official instrument is on hexaco.org.
Which one should you take
- You want a description of stable traits with research behind it: Big Five, ideally a long version.
- You want to understand your motivations and defences in narrative form: the Enneagram, read with the caveat above.
- You want a validated handle on honesty, greed and modesty: HEXACO.
- You want to look at seven named temptations and see which one runs your week: this test, in about three minutes.
- You want all of it: take ours first, then a Big Five, and compare the vice that scored highest against the trait that scored highest. The interesting question is not which tool wins but whether they agree.
None of these is a diagnosis. A self-selected online quiz cannot be one, and a 300-item instrument administered properly still describes a distribution rather than a person.
Further reading
- The research instrument behind the seven: Veselka, L., Giammarco, E. A., & Vernon, P. A. (2014). The Dark Triad and the seven deadly sins. Personality and Individual Differences, 64, 77–81 — publisher record.
- How this site scores its own 35 questions, and what the percentages do and do not mean: how the test works.
- The seven vices, their Latin names, and where the list came from: the 7 deadly sins list.
- The virtues set against each vice: the 7 heavenly virtues.
Questions about the comparison
Is the 7 deadly sins test the same as a personality test?
Only loosely. A personality test measures stable traits that are scored against a population. Our test asks how much seven specific temptations sound like you and shows the spread as percentages. It tells you where your answers landed, not what kind of person you are.
Which is more accurate, the Enneagram or Big Five?
Big Five, by a wide margin in the research literature — it is built from factor analysis of trait words and has decades of published reliability data. The Enneagram was developed as a teaching system rather than from academic research, and psychologists have argued about its measurement properties for decades. That does not make the Enneagram useless; it makes it a different kind of tool.
Should I take this test or a Big Five test?
Different questions. Take Big Five if you want a description of stable traits with research behind it. Take this one if you want to look at seven named temptations and see which one runs your week. Some people do both and find the sin that lines up with their highest neuroticism score the most interesting part.
Does HEXACO measure the seven deadly sins?
No, but one of its six dimensions comes close to the idea. HEXACO adds Honesty-Humility, which covers sincerity, fairness, greed avoidance and modesty — that is a close relative of pride and greed. It still measures dimensions rather than named vices.
Is there a validated scale for the seven deadly sins?
Yes: the Vices and Virtues Scales, developed and validated by Veselka, Giammarco and Vernon in 2014, seventy items, published in Personality and Individual Differences. It is a research instrument rather than a public quiz. Our 35 questions are our own and are not calibrated against it.